Penticton judge gets no help from Crown in sending message to criminals

PENTICTON – A Penticton judge, poised to send a strong message to Penticton criminals today, Feb. 1, looked to Crown Counsel for evidence of increasing incidents of crime in the city, but failed to get it.

Judge Gregory Koturbash said he was aware of a perception of increased crime in Penticton and sought added information from Crown to justify harsher penalties for the city’s habitual offenders.

The request for more information came at a sentencing hearing for Jeffery James Pelly, who pleaded guilty this morning to numerous charges, including theft under $5,000, possession of a controlled substance, breach, possession of stolen property and resisting arrest.

Pelly was also subject of some media notoriety after being arrested a couple of hours after receiving bail on Dec. 29, 2015.

Calling Penticton a “community under siege” Judge Koturbash said he wanted to address the issue of increased crime in the community. He called for court to stand down this morning to allow time for Crown to review the case before him, but Crown Prosecutor Vern Frolick said upon reconvening Crown did not have evidence to conclude crime is increasing in Penticton. He said it appeared to be nothing more than a “serious issue in the community.”

Defence lawyer James Pennington asked rhetorically: “How do we get to that conclusion?” answering, “Constant reporting in the media.”

Judge Koturbash said he was struggling with the issue, stating he reads the news and noted daily stories about break and enters in Penticton.

He adjourned his decision until tomorrow, February 2.

At the Jan. 21 Regional District of Okanagan Similkameen board meeting, Penticton RCMP Superintendent Kevin Hewco delivered his fourth quarter report to the board, informing them then that property crimes were high, not just in the city, but everywhere.

To contact the reporter for this story, email Steve Arstad at sarstad@infonews.ca or call 250-488-3065. To contact the editor, email mjones@infonews.ca or call 250-718-2724.

Join the Conversation!

Want to share your thoughts, add context, or connect with others in your community?

Steve Arstad

I have been looking for news in the South Okanagan - SImilkameen for 20 years, having turned a part time lifelong interest into a full time profession. After five years publishing a local newsletter, several years working as a correspondent / stringer for several local newspapers and seven years as editor of a Similkameen weekly newspaper, I joined iNFOnews.ca in 2014. My goal in the news industry has always been to deliver accurate and interesting articles about local people and places. My interest in the profession is life long - from my earliest memories of grade school, I have enjoyed writing.
As an airborne geophysical surveyor I travelled extensively around the globe, conducting helicopter borne mineral surveys.
I also spent several years at an Okanagan Falls based lumber mill, producing glued-wood laminated products.
As a member of the Kaleden community, I have been involved in the Kaleden Volunteer Fire Department for 22 years, and also serve as a trustee on the Kaleden Irrigation District board.
I am currently married to my wife Judy, of 26 years. We are empty-nesters who enjoy living in Kaleden with our Welsh Terrier, Angus, and cat, Tibbs.
Our two daughters, Meagan and Hayley, reside in Richmond and Victoria, respectively.

Steve Arstad's Stories